75 Railroad Ave, Middletown, NY 10940 (845) 343-8842
There are some traditions that you just can't beat and that certainly includes the amazing Italian recipes served up here that have been passed down from generation to generation. The hearty meals served up here are so comforting, you are going to find yourself returning for more often. And the fine wines that are available complement every entree option. Don't be surprised if the owner comes around to your table and checks on you, they really care whether you are satisfied or not. Is it a fancy place? No, but once you start eating none of that is going to matter to you.
Cosimos Brick Oven
620 Route 211 E, Middletown, NY 10941 (845) 692-3242
Let the amber glow of this wonderful establishment bring your heart and mind to a very calm place. The wood-fired brick oven sets such a beautiful tone that you are not going to want to leave. Sophisticated is another word we would use in describing an experience at this amazing establishment. The vaulted ceiling, the faux painted walls and the cherry wood accents accentuate the open floor plan and provides the perfect backdrop. The pizza is out of this world and surprise, surprise, they have gluten free options and some of the freshest toppings you could ever dream of.
Mix N Mac
280 Route 211 E, Middletown, NY 10940 (845) 381-5536
Who doesn't love mac n cheese? And at this amazing venue, they take one of the best foods of all time and take it to the next level. They have something here that you have probably never thought about before, they call them balls. They are fresh rolled mac n cheese which are lightly breaded then deep fried to golden perfection and finally served with their creamy cheesy tomato dipping sauce. They even offer something called Lobster Mac which incorporates lobster, roasted shallots, tarragon sherry cream sauce and mozzarella. And that is just the beginning of all of the fun.
DeStefano's Olde Erie
7 W Main St, Middletown, NY 10940 (845) 342-4908
If we could say one thing about this special establishment it would be that here is where you will find the very best food around and an atmosphere to match. All of the recipes used here are authentic and have been passed down from generation to generation. The staff takes great pains in making sure that the ingredients are as fresh as possible. The entrees listed on the menu are all bursting with extreme flavor. And talk about phenomenal service. The dedicated staff here are all attentive, super friendly and very knowledgeable about anything and everything you might need to know about this place.
Blue Chip Burger
368 E Main St, Middletown, NY 10940 (845) 344-2583
It has taken many years of working on it, but the staff at this venue have finally reached the place where they can confidently say that their establishment is the premier burger restaurant in all of the Hudson Valley. No, this isn't one of those franchises that are taking over the world, this is a true mom and pop location that will blow you right out of the water. They are looking out for one person's interests and that person is you, the customer. When you step inside you are going to find a quaint, cozy, homey dining environment that serves the highest quality meat with an array of great choices.
Mr Sushi & Grill
400 Route 211 E, Middletown, NY 10940 (845) 343-8788
Before we talk about anything else, we have to mention the Chilean Sea Bass. One bite and you will feel like you are in food heaven, it is that phenomenal. The staff is efficient and truly aim to take care of your every desire. If you are a sushi fan, get ready to be very impressed with the freshness and quality of what this venue has available. The hibachi preparation is done in such a professional manner. We would highly recommend this establishment and we have a feeling that you may want to pen this location in as a go to place. Don't miss this gem.